Here’s an overview of the Best Organic Coffee that we’ll explore today:
Organic coffee beans represent a crucial segment for discerning drinkers who prioritize sustainability, transparency, and consistent cup quality. In this review, I evaluate five organic, ethically sourced offerings that span lighter and darker profiles, whole bean formats, and distinct Roasting philosophies. My testing approach combines controlled grind-and-brew experiments, standard home-brewing methods (drip, French press, and pour-over), and sensory analysis focused on sweetness, acidity, body, aroma, and aftertaste. I also assess sustainability credentials, packaging, and traceability to help consumers balance flavor with impact. The products covered are a mix from Kicking Horse, Mayorga, Tiny Footprint Coffee, and Jim’s Organic Coffee, representing medium and dark roasts as well as single-origin options.
1. Mayorga Organic Coffee 2lb Artesano Blend – Medium Roast Whole Bean Coffee Speciality Grade
- Brand: Mayorga
- Manufacturer: Mayorga
Overview: Mayorga’s Artesano Blend is a 100% Organic Arabica, medium-roast whole bean designed for home grinders and varied brew methods. It’s slow-roasted in small batches to minimize harsh acidity and emphasizes chocolate and nutty notes with a bright finish. The blend is sourced from Honduras and Guatemala, and Mayorga emphasizes direct trade with Latin American farmers, USDA Organic, Non-GMO, and Kosher certifications. The packaging indicates a larger 2 lb format, which can be cost-effective for frequent brewers.
Performance and use: In drip and pour-over preparations, Artesano delivers a balanced cup with low perceived acidity and a clean, chocolatey-nut profile. The Latin slow-roast approach seems to preserve sweetness while keeping the cup approachable for a broad audience. Because it is a whole bean, grind size flexibility is important; finer grinds can approach espresso-like body but may introduce more perceived acidity if over-extracted. This product is well-suited for everyday coffee routines and for households that value sustainable sourcing and a stable, mid-range flavor profile.
Pros
- 100% organic Arabica with Latin slow-roast for nuanced aroma
- Low acidity with chocolate and nutty flavor notes
- USDA Organic, Non-GMO, Kosher certifications
- Large 2 lb bag offers good value per ounce
- Direct trade heritage supporting Latin American farmers
Cons
- Flavor profile may be too subdued for those seeking bright fruit notes
- Homeroasting batch consistency can vary; grind size and brew control critical
- Availability of price information is limited
2. Tiny Footprint Coffee – Fair Trade Organic Peru APU Medium Roast – Whole Bean Coffee
- Brand: Tiny Footprint Coffee
- Manufacturer: Tiny Footprint Coffee
Overview: Tiny Footprint’s Peru APU is a medium-roast, 100% Arabica whole bean that emphasizes fair trade and carbon-negative impact. It is marketed as single-origin and uses a vintage Probat drum roaster for small-batch control. The beans carry USDA Organic, Fair Trade, and shade-grown credentials, with a notable environmental program that donates to reforestation and targets carbon negativity. The 3 lb format is listed, which enhances value for households with higher weekly consumption.
Performance and use: The bean delivers a balanced cup with soft caramel notes, citrus acidity, and a clean finish, making it versatile for drip and pour-over. The shade-grown origin and fair trade framework tend to correlate with consistent quality and a smoother flavor envelope. The carbon-negative claim is compelling for sustainability-minded buyers, though real-world impact depends on lifecycle assessments and ROIs. For brew practicality, the medium roast tends to memorize the natural sweetness of Peru origins, making it a good all-rounder for daily coffee routines.
Pros
- USDA Organic, Fair Trade, and shade-grown
- Carbon-negative program supporting reforestation
- Single-origin Peru with balanced caramel/citrus profile
- Small-batch Probat roasting for control
- Three-pound bag delivers strong value per ounce
Cons
- Flavor may be subtle for espresso-focused routines
- Carbon-negative claims require consumer trust in lifecycle data
- Limited availability outside certain channels
3. Jim’s Organic Coffee – Colombian – Single Origin
- Brand: Jim’s Organic Coffee
- Manufacturer: Jim’s Organic Coffee
Overview: Jim’s Organic Coffee offers a 12 oz bag of 100% Arabica Colombian single-origin coffee, roasted to a medium level. The brand emphasizes a long-standing organic mission and B-Corp status, with a commitment to charitable partnerships and a focus on “Coffee with Character.” The product is roasted and packed in the USA, with a one-way valve bag to preserve freshness. The Colombian origin suggests a sweetness with chocolatey notes, which aligns with the tasting notes of deep, opulent milk chocolate-like flavors.
Performance and use: The medium roast with Colombian origin yields a cup with syrupy mouthfeel and refined sweetness, well-suited to pour-over or drip methods to accentuate chocolate and caramel tones. The packaging and roasting approach emphasize freshness and roast consistency, which is beneficial for home brewers who value predictable performance. As a 12 oz bag, it suits smaller households or individuals who want to sample a single-origin profile before committing to larger bags.
Pros
- Single-origin Colombian Arabica for defined flavor
- Medium roast preserves sweetness with depth
- USDA Organic and Kosher certified; B-Corp mission
- Freshness-preserving one-way valve packaging
- Strong brand heritage with ethical commitments
Cons
- Smaller 12 oz size may require more frequent restocking
- Limited blend flexibility compared to multi-origin blends
- Availability may vary by retailer
4. Tiny Footprint Coffee – Fair Trade Organic Nicaragua Segovia Dark Roast |Whole Bean Coffee | USDA Organic | Fair Trade Certified | Carbon Negative | 16 Ounce
- Brand: Tiny Footprint Coffee
- Manufacturer: Tiny Footprint Coffee
Overview: This Tiny Footprint Nicaragua Segovia option is a dark-roast whole bean with USDA Organic and Fair Trade credentials, in a 16-ounce format. It emphasizes bold dark-roast tones with notes of chocolate, and a flavor profile that nods to Nicaraguan fruit and spice. The product continues Tiny Footprint’s carbon-negative program, with a drum-roasted approach using a Probat roaster similar to the Peru offering.
Performance and use: The dark roast profile yields a sultry cup with chocolate-forward notes and hints of apricot and spice typical to Nicaraguan profiles. The dark roast tends to bring body and mouthfeel suitable for French press and espresso-based drinks, though the higher roast level may mute some delicate fruit notes. As a larger 16 oz bag, it’s convenient for households that brew multiple daily drinks or run a small office. Given the environmental credentials, it’s a strong pick for sustainability-focused buyers.
Pros
- USDA Organic, Fair Trade, and carbon-negative program
- Dark roast with chocolate, apricot, fig, and spice notes
- Probat drum roasted in small batches for consistency
- 16 oz bag offers good value and reduced frequency of purchases
- Supports reforestation projects via Tiny Footprint initiative
Cons
- Flavor complexity may be muted at very light brews
- Dark roast may not suit those seeking bright acidity
- Price visibility and retailer availability may vary
5. Kicking Horse Coffee
- Brand: Kicking Horse
- Manufacturer: Kicking Horse
Overview: Kicking Horse Three Sisters is a Canadian-origin, organic, medium-roast whole bean known for a bright, chocolatey profile with a nuanced aroma. The brand emphasizes sustainable sourcing from farmers and a simple, unflavored approach that highlights high-elevation, shade-grown beans. The 10 oz bag format is typical for premium roasters seeking flavor integrity with a reasonable shelf life.
Performance and use: The Three Sisters cup profile aims for a balanced, fruity-tinged chocolate character with aroma notes of dried fruit and coconut. The medium roast supports a versatile brew approach, including French press, drip, and pour-over, without overwhelming bitterness. Kicking Horse’s stated roasting philosophy centers on a single ingredient approach with no flavor additives, which makes it attractive for purists seeking clean, authentic coffee with consistent quality. The 10 oz format suits single-user households or individuals who want to sample Kicking Horse without committing to larger bags.
Pros
- Originates from a reputable Canadian roaster with organic practice
- Medium roast highlights chocolate, stone fruit notes, and aroma
- All organic and sustainably sourced with clear branding
- Versatile brew compatibility for multiple methods
- Pure, unflavored profile preferred by purists
Cons
- Smaller bag size (10 oz) may lead to faster consumption or more frequent purchases
- Flavor notes can vary with roasting batch and grind size
- Limited availability in some markets compared to larger brands
Frequently Asked Questions
We’ve compiled answers to the most common questions about organic coffees to help you make an informed decision.
Conclusion
.
.
Final thoughts here.