Here’s an overview of the Best Hiking Shoes that we’ll explore today:
Hiking shoes are the most-used piece of gear for most adventures, balancing comfort, protection, weight, and durability across varied terrain. A great pair can turn a grueling day into a confident trek, while the wrong pair may cause hot spots, lack of stability, or water ingress. In this comparison, I tested five hiking footwear options across price tiers and brand philosophies to help readers match their needs to real-world performance. My methodology combines out-of-box fit assessment, material and construction analysis, midsole and outsole performance, waterproofing, breathability, and long-term durability indicators. I evaluated fit feel, stability on uneven surfaces, traction across dry and wet conditions, insulation/breathability, and ease of maintenance. The lineup includes a premium everyday-hiker benchmark (Merrell Moab 3), two Columbia options that emphasize value and protection, a KEEN with a wide-toe-box design, and a budget outdoor boot from OUTJET.
1. Merrell Men’s Moab 3 Hiking Shoe
- Brand: Merrell
- Manufacturer: Merrell
Overview: The Merrell Moab 3 continues a long-standing legacy as a best-selling all-around hiker. It features a revised insole for improved support, a softer midsole for comfort, a grippier Vibram outsole, and partially recycled fabrics, aiming to blend plug-and-play comfort with robust durability. Its reputation among hikers for immediate comfort and versatile performance is a core selling point, and the Moab 3 builds on that heritage with incremental but meaningful updates.
Performance-wise, the Moab 3 shines on moderate trails with mixed surfaces. The upgraded insole supports the foot arc well for long days, while the cushioned midsole helps absorb impact on rocky sections. The Vibram outsole provides dependable grip in dry and damp conditions, though its feel may be firmer on extremely loose scree. Fit tends to be roomier in the forefoot, which is favorable for wider feet or for swelling over long hikes; however, it can feel slightly loose for skinnier-footed wearers unless cinched with the laces. The Moab 3 scores high on versatility, making it a safe daily trainer for varied terrain, but it’s not a specialized mountaineering boot or lightweight speed-hiker. For those seeking a no-fuss boot with proven durability, this is a top-tier option.
Pros
- Renowned comfort and immediate break-in feel
- Upgraded insole and softer midsole for all-day support
- Grippy Vibram outsole improves traction on varied terrain
- Partially recycled fabrics enhance sustainability
Cons
- Forefoot volume may be too roomy for narrow feet
- Not the lightest option in its category
- Traction may underperform on icy surfaces without proper traction aids
2. Men’s Waterproof Hiking Boots Lightweight Comfortable Leather Mid Ankle Outdoor Trekking Boot
- Brand: OUTJET
- Manufacturer: OUTJET
Overview: This OUTJET model appears as a budget-friendly waterproof mid-ankle option designed for everyday trail use. It emphasizes lightweight construction with leather accents and a waterproofing layer intended to handle light rain and damp trails. The price point under $40 positions it as an entry-level choice for hikers who prioritize value and basic weather protection over high-end materials or specialized performance.
In practice, the OUTJET boot offers predictable, no-nonsense performance for casual day hikes and urban-adventure days. Waterproofing helps during sudden showers or crossing shallow streams, and the leather mid-ankle design provides ankle support for light-to-moderate trails. However, given the sub-$40 price, expect trade-offs in outsole grip, midsole cushioning, and overall durability relative to mid-range and premium models. Maintenance becomes important—regular conditioning of leather and reproofing will extend life, and users should be mindful of heat or harsh conditions that could compromise waterproof membranes over time. This model is best for first-time hikers or budget-conscious buyers who don’t require advanced trail tech.
Pros
- Excellent value for a waterproof mid-ankle boot
- Lightweight construction reduces fatigue on easy trails
- Leather accents offer a classic look and structure
- Simple, straightforward waterproofing for wet conditions
Cons
- Overall durability and outsole grip may lag behind pricier rivals
- Cushioning and energy return are limited
- Waterproof membrane longevity can vary with use
3. Columbia Women’s Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped Hiking Boot
- Brand: Columbia
- Manufacturer: Columbia
Overview: The Columbia Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped is a versatile, value-oriented option designed to tackle varied terrain with a focus on waterproof protection and comfortable fit. While this listing references a women’s model, the Newton Ridge family is known for offering balanced support, moderate insulation, and dependable traction, making it a practical choice for a wide range of hikers who value reliability and value.
Performance-wise, Newton Ridge Plus Waterproof Amped provides consistent protection and comfort for day hikes in mixed weather. The waterproofing helps with rain and stream crossings, while the outsole offers solid traction on dirt and damp surfaces. The boot’s midsole cushioning is adequate for most day hikes, though it may feel firmer for longer treks or heavier users. The overall package emphasizes plug-and-play usability, with a broad size range and forgiving fit, making it ideal for hikers who want a straightforward boot that requires little customization. For those on a budget who still want Columbia’s reliability, this is a compelling option.
Pros
- Reliable waterproof protection
- Balanced comfort and stability for day hikes
- Good value for price
- Wide size range and forgiving fit
Cons
- Not the lightest option in its class
- May lack aggressive traction for technical terrain
- Upper materials may show wear with heavy use
4. KEEN Men’s Targhee 4 Waterproof Hiking Shoes
- Brand: KEEN
- Manufacturer: KEEN
Overview: KEEN’s Targhee 4 remains a staple in the brand’s lineup with a durable direct-attach construction, KEEN.DRY waterproofing, and all-terrain traction. Known for a wider-than-average fit, the Targhee 4 is built to handle rugged terrain with a robust overall footprint and long-term durability. At $119.50, it sits in the premium-value tier, offering a blend of rugged protection and out-of-the-box comfort.
Performance-wise, the Targhee 4 delivers confident grip on rocky trails and damp surfaces due to KEEN’s all-terrain tread. The wider fit is beneficial for toe splay on long days and for hikers with wider feet or swollen feet. The waterproof lining helps with light rain and slush, while the overall construction supports heavy use and mixed weather. Some users may find the wider fit less ideal for narrow feet, and the boot may feel slightly heavier than some lightweight hikers. The durability and KEEN’s ethos around environmental responsibility add intangible value beyond pure performance.
Pros
- Wide fit accommodating toe splay
- Durable construction and direct-attach outsole
- KEEN.DRY waterproofing for wet conditions
- Excellent traction on mixed terrain
Cons
- Slightly heavier than some rivals
- Wider fit may feel loose for narrow feet
- Viewed as premium-priced by some budgets
5. Columbia Men’s Newton Ridge Plus II Suede Waterproof Hiking Boots
- Brand: Columbia
- Manufacturer: Columbia
Overview: This Newton Ridge Plus II option from Columbia emphasizes suede with waterproofing for a casual-to-mid-range hiking footprint. It offers a budget-friendly price point while delivering Columbia’s reputation for reliability and comfort in outdoor footwear. The suede upper brings a classic look and moderate durability, paired with a waterproof layer to tackle damp conditions.
In terms of use, the Newton Ridge II Suede is well-suited for weekend hikes, light rain, and daily wear on mixed trails. Cushioning is generally comfortable for moderate distances, and the transition from pavement to dirt is smooth thanks to a stable midsole. The suede upper, while stylish, may require more maintenance to prevent water intrusion and staining compared to full-grain leather or synthetic uppers. Overall, this option represents strong value for hikers who want dependable performance without breaking the bank.
Pros
- Budget-friendly price
- Solid waterproofing for light to moderate wet conditions
- Comfortable for day trips and casual hiking
- Good durability for price point
Cons
- Suede upper requires maintenance to stay water-resistant
- Not the lightest or most springy midsole
- Traction may be less aggressive on technical terrain
Frequently Asked Questions
We’ve compiled answers to the most common questions about hiking shoess to help you make an informed decision.
Conclusion
The evaluated lineup demonstrates a spectrum from budget-friendly to premium, with the Merrell Moab 3 delivering the strongest generalist performance and the KEEN Targhee 4 offering a purpose-built wider fit and rugged durability.
For hikers prioritizing value and predictable waterproof performance, Columbia options deliver solid options at compelling prices, while OUTJET provides an entry point for budget-conscious buyers who aren’t chasing peak technical performance.
Choose based on foot width, typical terrain, and how much you value waterproofing versus weight and cushioning..